| Year |
School |
*Offensive Player of the Year |
Defensive Player of the Year |
Newcomer of the Year |
Coach of the Year |
| 2025 |
Grove City! |
Tori Stevenson, Grove City |
Hannah Costa, Grove City |
Lauren Muhanna, Grove City |
Melissa Lamie, Grove City |
| 2024 |
Grove City! |
Emma Miller, Allegheny |
Morgan Murphy, Westminster |
Eva Dexter, Franciscan |
Girish Thakar, Westminster |
| 2023 |
Grove City! |
Emma Herrmann, Grove City |
Sophia Galietta, Westminster |
Chloe LaRosa, Westminster |
Bryan Butler, Saint Vincent |
| 2022 |
Westminster! |
Tania Davidson, Franciscan |
|
Morgan Murphy, Westminster |
Sarah Salamida, Franciscan |
| 2021 |
Chatham! |
Morgan Anderson, Chatham |
|
Brooke Horvath, Westminster |
Betsy Warren, Chatham |
| 2020-21 |
Chatham |
Morgan Anderson, Chatham |
|
Gianna D'Amato, Grove City |
Betsy Warren, Chatham |
| 2019 |
Grove City! |
Ruby Mattson, Grove City |
|
Julia Redilla, Westminster |
Melissa Lamie, Grove City |
| 2018 |
Grove City! |
Krista Heckman, Grove City |
|
|
Melissa Lamie, Grove City |
| 2017 |
Thomas More! |
Lindsay Hutton, Grove City |
|
|
Melissa Lamie, Grove City |
| 2016 |
Thomas More! |
Laura Felix, Thomas More |
|
|
Betsy Warren, Chatham |
| 2015 |
Thomas More! |
Jordan Toohey, W&J |
|
|
Jeff Cummings, Thomas More |
| 2014 |
Thomas More! |
Olivia Huber, Thomas More |
|
|
Jeff Cummings, Thomas More |
| 2013 |
Thomas More! |
Holly Shipley, W&J |
|
|
Jeff Cummings, Thomas More |
| 2012 |
Thomas More! |
Abby Gindling, Thomas More |
|
|
Melissa Lamie, Grove City |
| 2011 |
Thomas More! |
Holly Shipley, W&J |
|
|
Jeff Cummings, Thomas More |
| 2010 |
W&J! |
Hannah Yang, Grove City |
|
|
Pete Curtis, W&J |
| 2009 |
W&J! |
Michelle Peck, Grove City |
|
|
Melissa Lamie, Grove City |
| 2008 |
W&J! |
Jackie Foltz, W&J |
|
|
Pete Curtis, W&J |
| 2007 |
Westminster! |
Brittany Yeggy, Thomas More |
|
|
Pete Curtis, W&J |
| 2006 |
Westminster |
Mallory Bugel, Westminster |
|
|
Girish Thakar, Westminster |
| 2005 |
Thomas More |
Mallory Bugel, Westminster |
|
|
Girish Thakar, Westminster |
| 2004 |
Westminster |
Kate Klingensmith, Grove City |
|
|
Melissa Lamie, Grove City |
| 2003 |
Westminster |
Meg Tilley, Grove City |
|
|
Melissa Lamie, Grove City |
| 2002 |
Westminster |
Tammy Newell, Westminster |
|
|
Girish Thakar, Westminster |
| 2001 |
Grove City |
Kathy Keehlwetter, Grove City |
|
|
Bryan Williams, Thiel |
| 2000 |
Grove City |
Nicole Bosley, W&J |
|
|
Melissa Lamie, Grove City |
| 1999 |
Bethany |
Amy Harvilla, Bethany |
|
|
Ken Alberta, Waynesburg |
| 1998 |
Waynesburg |
Lisa Juskowich, Waynesburg |
|
|
Ken Alberta, Waynesburg |
| 1997 |
Grove City |
Jody Swauger-Simms, Grove City |
|
|
Melissa Lamie, Grove City |
| 1996 |
Grove City |
Erin Korns, Waynesburg |
|
|
Melissa Lamie, Grove City |
| 1995 |
Grove City |
Missy Miller, Bethany |
|
|
Melissa Van Heukelem (Lamie), Grove City |
| 1994 |
Bethany |
Missy Miller, Bethany |
|
|
Melissa Van Heukelem (Lamie), Grove City |
| 1993 |
Bethany |
Missy Miller, Bethany |
|
|
Jan Forsty, Bethany |
| 1992 |
Bethany |
Kelsey Barber, Bethany |
|
|
Jan Forsty, Bethany |
| 1991 |
Bethany |
Kelsey Barber/Kelli Marsteller, Bethany |
|
|
Jan Forsty, Bethany |
|
|
|
|
|
|
! - Received PAC's automatic qualifying bid to the NCAA Division III Championship
Updated: November 7, 2023 |