| 2023 PAC Men's Cross Country Preseason Coaches' Poll (Predicted order of finish) |
| School (first-place votes) |
Points |
2022 Conference finishes |
| 1. Allegheny College (6) |
90 |
2nd (of 10) at PAC Championships, 56 pts. |
| 2. Saint Vincent College (3) |
85 |
4th (of 10) at PAC Championships, 80 pts. |
| 3. Geneva College (2) |
84 |
3rd (of 10) at PAC Championships, 67 pts. |
| 4. Washington & Jefferson College |
70 |
6th (of 10) at PAC Championships, 132 pts. |
| 5. Grove City College |
68 |
5th (of 10) at PAC Championships, 114 pts. |
| 6. Franciscan University |
60 |
1st (of 10) at PAC Championships, 41 pts. |
| 7. Waynesburg University |
50 |
7th (of 10) at PAC Championships, 211 pts. |
| 8. Chatham University |
32 |
9th (of 10) at PAC Championships, 272 pts. |
| 9. Thiel College |
24 |
8th (of 10) at PAC Championships, 246 pts. |
| 10. Westminster College |
24 |
10th (of 10) at PAC Championships, 293 pts. |
| 11. Bethany College |
18 |
Individuals only at PAC Championships |