| 2019 |
Saint Vincent |
Player of the Year: Saint Vincent freshman P Celia Knappenberger
Coach of the Year: Saint Vincent's Nicole Karr |
|
|
| 2018 |
Thomas More |
Player of the Year: Westminster senior P Jazmyn Rohrer
Coach of the Year: Bethany's Jan Forsty |
|
|
| 2017 |
Thomas More |
Player of the Year: Thomas More sophomore P Alix DeDreu
Coach of the Year: Thomas More's Lindsay Eagan |
|
|
| 2016 |
Saint Vincent |
Player of the Year: Saint Vincent junior P Samantha Emert
Coach of the Year: Saint Vincent's Nicole Hinerman-Karr |
|
|
| 2015 |
Thomas More |
Player of the Year: Grove City senior SS Kelsey Shirey
Coach of the Year: Bethany's Jan Forsty |
|
|
| 2014 |
W&J |
Player of the Year: Thomas More sophomore SS Ana Walter
Coach of the Year: W&J's Nicole Vitello |
| 2013 |
Thomas More |
Player of the Year: Thomas More junior 3B Alex Walter
Coach of the Year: Thomas More's Lindsay Bramhall |
| 2012 |
Geneva |
Player of the Year: Geneva senior P Julie DiLonardo
Coach of the Year: Geneva's Van Zanic |
| 2011 |
Bethany |
Player of the Year: Bethany senior 3B Andrea Thomas
Coach of the Year: Bethany's Jan Forsty |
| 2010 |
Thomas More |
Player of the Year: Thomas More sophomore 3B Brittany Wegman
Coach of the Year: Thomas More's Lindsay Bramhall |
| 2009 |
Thomas More |
Player of the Year: Thomas More sophomore P Dana Bors
Coach of the Year: Thomas More's Lindsay Bramhall |
| 2008 |
Bethany |
Player of the Year: W&J senior OF Amanda Howard
Coach of the Year: W&J's Nicole Vitello |
| 2007 |
Thomas More |
Player of the Year: Westminster senior P Jennifer Pancake
Coach of the Year: Westminster's Jan Reddinger |
| 2006 |
Washington & Jefferson |
Player of the Year: Thomas More junior 3B Kim Kreimer
Coach of the Year: Thomas More's Everett Roper |
| 2005 |
Westminster |
Player of the Year: Bethany senior IF Heather Bainey
Pitcher of the Year: Bethany junior Romney Waters
Coach of the Year: Bethany's Jan Forsty |
| 2004 |
Bethany |
Player of the Year: Bethany senior 3B Janice Masters
Co-Pitchers of the Year: Bethany sophomore Romney Waters, Grove City senior Allison Atwood, Westminster freshman Jennifer Pancake
Freshman of the Year: Westminster P/DH Jennifer Pancake
Co-Coaches of the Year: Bethany's Jan Forsty, Westminster's Jan Reddinger |
| 2003 |
Bethany |
Player of the Year: Bethany senior P Rachel Schafer
Pitcher of the Year: Bethany senior Rachel Schafer
Freshman of the Year: Waynesburg IF/OF Tina Ramer
Coach of the Year: Bethany's Jan Forsty |
| 2002 |
Bethany |
Player of the Year: Bethany junior P/IF Rachel Schafer
Pitcher of the Year: Bethany junior Rachel Schafer
Freshman of the Year: W&J C/OF Jill Shields
Co-Coaches of the Year: Bethany's Jan Forsty, W&J's Emily Houghton |
| 2001 |
Bethany |
Player of the Year: Bethany sophomore P Rachael Schafer
Coach of the Year: Bethany's Jan Forsty |
| 2000 |
Bethany (PAC's inaugural championship softball tournament) |
Player of the Year: Bethany senior C Jaime Derthick
Coach of the Year: Bethany's Jan Forsty |
| 1999 |
Bethany |
Player of the Year: Thiel junior SS Tracy Henderson
Coach of the Year: Bethany's Jan Forsty |
| 1998 |
Grove City |
Player of the Year: Thiel sophomore SS Tracy Henderson
Coach of the Year: Grove City's Susan Roberts |
| 1997 |
Bethany |
Player of the Year: Bethany senior 3B Wendy Shaffer
Pitcher of the Year: Bethany junior Jodi Jackfert
Coach of the Year: Bethany's Jan Forsty |
| 1996 |
W&J |
Player of the Year: W&J senior SS Tricia Lander
Coach of the Year: W&J's Kim Wilson |
| 1995 |
Bethany |
| 1994 |
Bethany |
Player of the Year: Bethany senior IF Nicole Mazur
Freshman of the Year: Bethany IF Wendy Shaffer
Coach of the Year: Bethany's Jan Forsty |
| 1993 |
Waynesburg |
Player of the Year: Bethany senior C Melanie Stumm
Freshman of the Year: W&J P Tricia Lander
Pitcher of the Year: Bethany junior LaDonna Tomei
Coach of the Year: W&J's Kim Wilson |
| 1992 |
Bethany |
Player of the Year: Bethany junior C Melanie Stumm
Coach of the Year: |
| 1991 |
|
Player of the Year: Bethany IF Lori Woods
Pitcher of the Year: Bethany sophomore Lori Schimmel
Coach of the Year: |
| 1990 |
Player of the Year: W&J junior 1B Amy Rush
Pitcher of the Year: Grove City senior Michele Kirin
Coach of the Year: Grove City's Cathy Jacobs |
| 1989 |
|
| 1988 |
Hiram |
| 1987 |
|
| 1986 |
Grove City |
Player of the Year: John Carroll freshman C Audrey Warnock
Pitcher of the Year: Bethany senior Monica Maryasz
Coach of the Year: Grove City's Don Lyle |