| Year |
Champion |
| 2025 |
Grove City |
Player of the Year: Grove City junior first baseman Colin Marinpetro
Pitcher of the Year: W&J senior Dante DiMatteo
Newcomer of the Year: Grove City freshman shortstop Sam Meredith
Coach of the Year: Grove City's Matt Royer |
| 2024 |
W&J |
Player of the Year: W&J junior shortstop Jacob LaDuca
Pitcher of the Year: Grove City senior Nick Guidas
Newcomer of the Year: Grove City freshman utility Sam Bevin
Coach of the Year: W&J's Jeff Mountain |
| 2023 |
W&J |
Player of the Year: W&J senior utility Tyler Horvat
Pitcher of the Year: W&J senior Tyler Horvat
Newcomer of the Year: Grove City freshman outfielder Nick Sampson
Coach of the Year: W&J's Jeff Mountain |
| 2022 |
W&J |
Player of the Year: W&J senior catcher Peter Kalinski
Pitcher of the Year: Grove City senior Tate Ostrowski
Newcomer of the Year: Grove City freshman utility Mally Kilbane
Coach of the Year: W&J's Jeff Mountain |
| 2021 |
W&J |
Player of the Year: W&J senior outfielder Adam Morris
Pitcher of the Year: W&J junior Henry Litman
Newcomer of the Year: W&J sophomore utility Tyler Horvat
Coach of the Year: W&J's Jeff Mountain |
|
|
| 2020 |
Cancelled |
|
|
| 2019 |
W&J |
Player of the Year: Thiel senior outfielder Nick Fowkes
Pitcher of the Year: W&J junior Ben Marsico
Coach of the Year: W&J's Jeff Mountain |
| 2018 |
Thomas More |
Player of the Year: Thomas More senior second baseman Ben Laumann
Pitcher of the Year: W&J senior Bryce Schnatterly
Coach of the Year: Thomas More's Jeff Hetzer |
| 2017 |
W&J |
Player of the Year: W&J senior catcher Derek Helbing
Pitcher of the Year: W&J senior Riley Groves
Coach of the Year: W&J's Jeff Mountain |
| 2016 |
Thomas More |
Player of the Year: Thiel senior pitcher, outfielder Matt Elko
Pitcher of the Year: Waynesburg senior Brian Resnik
Coach of the Year: Thomas More's Jeff Hetzer |
| 2015 |
W&J |
Player of the Year: Thomas More junior designated hitter Donovan Pogue
Co-Pitchers of the Year: W&J sophomore Riley Groves, Waynesburg junior Brian Resnik
Coach of the Year: W&J's Jeff Mountain |
| 2014 |
Thomas More |
Player of the Year: W&J senior outfielder Josh Staniscia
Pitcher of the Year: W&J senior Eddie Nogay
Coach of the Year: Thomas More's Jeff Hetzer |
| 2013 |
W&J |
Player of the Year: Thiel senior pitcher, first baseman Nick Rossmiller
Pitcher of the Year: W&J junior Eddie Nogay
Coach of the Year: W&J's Jeff Mountain |
| 2012 |
Westminster |
Player of the Year: Westminster senior first baseman Tim Wiand
Pitcher of the Year: W&J senior David Trushel
Coach of the Year: Westminster's Carmen Nocera |
| 2011 |
Thomas More |
Player of the Year: Thomas More junior first baseman Andrew Thole
Pitcher of the Year: Grove City senior Cory Metcalf
Coach of the Year: Thomas More's Jeff Hetzer |
| 2010 |
Thomas More |
Player of the Year: W&J senior outfielder, pitcher Jim Pasquine
Pitcher of the Year: Thomas More sophomore Paul Uhl
Coach of the Year: Bethany's Rick Carver |
| 2009 |
W&J |
Player of the Year: W&J junior outfielder, pitcher Jim Pasquine
Coach of the Year: W&J's Jeff Mountain |
| 2008 |
Grove City |
Player of the Year: Grove City senior outfielder Brian Moran
Coach of the Year: Grove City's Rob Skaricich |
| 2007 |
W&J |
Player of the Year: W&J senior pitcher, first baseman Sam Mann
Coach of the Year: W&J's Jeff Mountain |
| 2006 |
W&J |
Player of the Year: Thomas More senior shortstop Brad Thoma
Coach of the Year: W&J's Jeff Mountain |
| 2005 |
Westminster |
Player of the Year: W&J sophomore third baseman Shaun Pfeil
Coach of the Year: Westminster's Carmen Nocera |
| 2004 |
W&J |
Player of the Year: Bethany senior pitcher, outfielder Matt Raiti
Coach of the Year: W&J's Jeff Mountain |
| 2003 |
Thiel |
Player of the Year: Waynesburg junior outfielder, pitcher Eric Holt
Coach of the Year: Thiel's Joe Schaly |
| 2002 |
Grove City |
Player of the Year: Thiel junior third baseman Randy Chiquelin
Coach of the Year: Grove City's Rob Skaricich |
| 2001 |
Grove City |
Player of the Year: Grove City senior outfielder Nate Kauffmann
Coach of the Year: Grove City's Rob Skaricich |
| 2000 |
Bethany |
Player of the Year: Bethany senior catcher Steve Opfermann
Coach of the Year: Bethany's Rick Carver |
| 1999 |
Bethany |
Player of the Year: Bethany junior catcher Steve Opfermann
Coach of the Year: Grove City's Rob Skaricich |
| 1998 |
Waynesburg |
Player of the Year: Waynesburg senior second baseman Adam Jack
Coach of the Year: Waynesburg's Mike Florak |
| 1997 |
W&J |
| 1996 |
Bethany |
Player of the Year: Bethany senior SS Jeff Weekley
Coach of the Year: Bethany's Rick Carver |
| 1995 |
Waynesburg |
| 1994 |
Waynesburg |
Player of the Year: Bethany junior C Jim Taylor
Coach of the Year: Waynesburg's Steve Lee |
| 1993 |
Waynesburg |
Player of the Year: Waynesburg senior OF Troy Funkhouser
Coach of the Year: Waynesburg's Steve Lee |
| 1992 |
W&J |
| 1991 |
Bethany |
| 1990 |
W&J |
| 1989 |
John Carroll |
Player of the Year: W&J senior C Pat Aigner
Pitcher of the Year: Hiram senior Matt Paul
Coach of the Year: John Carroll's Jerry Schweickert |
| 1988 |
John Carroll |
Player of the Year: John Carroll senior SS Jerry Auld
Pitcher of the Year: John Caroll senior Doug Dickason
Coach of the Year: John Carroll's Jerry Schweickert |
| 1987 |
John Carroll |
Player of the Year: Thiel junior P Larry Fowkes
Pitcher of the Year: John Carroll sophomore Chris Shepherd
Coach of the Year: Thiel's Wayne Petrarca |
| 1986 |
W&J |
Player of the Year: W&J senior SS Mike Savrese
Coach of the Year: W&J's John Luckhardt |
| 1985 |
John Caroll |
Player of the Year: John Carroll senior P Steve Healy
Pitcher of the Year: John Carroll senior P Brian Clarke
Coach of the Year: John Carroll's Jerry Schweickert |
| 1984 |
John Carroll |
Player of the Year: John Carroll junior 1B Bill Thompson
Pitcher of the Year: John Carroll junior Brian Clarke |
| 1983 |
John Carroll |
| 1982 |
John Carroll |
| Player of the Year: Hiram senior P Doug Gruber |
| 1981 |
Thiel |
| Player of the Year: Thiel senior P Dave Rhodes |
| 1980 |
John Carroll |
| Player of the Year: Hiram OF Pat Gianell |
| 1979 |
Bethany |
| Player of the Year: Bethany C Scott Lanz |
| 1978 |
Hiram |
| 1977 |
Allegheny |
| 1976 |
Allegheny/John Carroll |
| 1975 |
Allegheny |
| 1974 |
Allegheny |
| 1973 |
Hiram |
| 1972 |
Allegheny |
| 1971 |
Allegheny |
| 1970 |
Allegheny/Bethany |
| 1969 |
Allegheny |
| 1968 |
Western Reserve |
| 1967 |
Allegheny/Bethany/Western Reserve |
| 1966 |
Allegheny |
| 1965 |
Bethany |
| 1964 |
Allegheny |
| 1963 |
Allegheny |
| 1962 |
Allegheny |
| 1961 |
Allegheny |
| 1960 |
Allegheny |
| 1959 |
Wayne State |
|
|