Allegheny's Valiant Effort Falls Short in ECAC Bowl Loss Versus St. John Fisher

Football | 11/21/2026 7:45:00 PM

MEADVILLE, Pa. (pacathletics.org) - The Allegheny College football team ended its upstart 2026 season with a hard-fought 24-21 loss to St. John Fisher University Saturday afternoon in the Robert M. "Scotty" Whitelaw Bowl.

Allegheny's (8-3) first-ever Eastern College Athletic Conference (ECAC) bowl appearance came down to the closing minutes. Trailing 24-14, the Gators earned a key stop, halting a 12-play Fisher (8-3) drive on the 10-yard line. With only 2:42 to go, the Gators answered with an 11-play, 90-yard drive of their own.
 
On second-and-two from the seven-yard line, quarterback Carson Colucci (Brewster, Ohio/Fairless) stepped up in the pocket and extended the play long enough to find receiver Terran Mitchell (St. Louis, Mo./Affton) on an in-breaking route in the end zone. Myles Knox (Pinnacle, N.C./West Stokes) converted the point-after attempt, cutting the deficit to three points with 35 seconds left in the fourth quarter.

Knox's ensuing onside kick took a good bounce, but was touched by an Allegheny player before traveling the required 10 yards. With no timeouts left, the Gators had to watch the Cardinals kneel out the remaining seconds to close out the victory.

Inside the Box Score
  • Allegheny's offense finished the contest with 273 yards, with 179 passing and 94 rushing.
  • St. John Fisher posted 431 total yards with 286 passing and 145 on the ground.
  • Colucci completed 23-of-38 passes (60.5%) for 179 yards and a pair of touchdowns.
  • Colucci scored the game's first touchdown early in the second quarter on a 13-yard pass to Remington Rossow (West Palm Beach, Fla./Forest Hill).
  • Rossow made seven catches for 64 yards, both team highs.
  • Fisher quarterback Ryan Whitney was named the Robert M. "Scotty" Whitelaw Bowl's MVP with 286 passing yards, 140 rushing yards, and three total touchdowns.
  • Whitney's favorite target, Jackson Cusack, had 10 receptions for 116 yards and one score.
  • Allegheny's defense picked off Whitney twice, with interceptions by Chase Weihrauch (Springdale, Pa./Springdale) and Coltin Colucci (Brewster, Ohio/Fairless).
  • Fisher defensive back Nate Parliment had seven tackles, a half-tackle for a loss, and a first-quarter interception in the end zone.
  • The difference in the final score was a 24-yard field goal by SJF kicker Logan Laratta in the second quarter.
News and Notes
  • Allegheny made its first-ever ECAC bowl appearance Saturday in the Robert M. "Scotty" Whitelaw Bowl.
  • On the other hand, St. John Fisher played in its 11th bowl game and won its first ECAC bowl since 2014.
  • The Gators and Cardinals also met in varsity competition for the first time in program history.
  • Both teams ended the year with an 8-3 record.
  • The Gators posted their first winning season since going 6-4 in 2018, while their eight wins are the most since going 8-2 in 2009.
  • Carson Colucci surpassed 2,000 passing yards in 2026, and his 21 passing touchdowns are the most by a Gator quarterback since Jack Johnson '24 threw 22 in 2021.
  • Weihrauch made his third interception of the season, tying for the team lead with corner Ashton Chambers (Bluffton, S.C./Bluffton).
  • As a team, the AC defense had 14 interceptions, the most in a season since the Blue & Gold recorded 16 in 2018.

Contributed ny Allegheny Athletic Communications