| 2019 All-Presidents' Athletic Conference (PAC) Softball Teams |
| First Team |
| Position |
Name |
Class |
School |
Hometown | High School |
| C |
Jennifer Oberthur |
Fr. |
Bethany |
Indianapolis, Ind. | Park Tudor |
| C |
Rachel Skon |
Jr. |
Waynesburg |
Pittsburgh, Pa. | Brashear |
| 1B |
Alex Lawrence |
Sr. |
Waynesburg |
Bridgeville, Pa. | Chartiers Valley |
| 2B |
Johnna Karas |
So. |
Saint Vincent |
North Huntingdon, Pa. | Norwin |
| SS |
Vanessa Falce |
Jr. |
Thiel |
McKeesport, Pa. | McKeesport |
| SS |
Rachel Johnson |
Sr. |
W&J |
Orchard Park, N.Y. | Orchard Park |
| 3B |
Alona Sleith |
So. |
Saint Vincent |
West Newton, Pa. | Yough |
| OF |
Kelly Flaherty |
Sr. |
Saint Vincent |
Pittsburgh, Pa. | Brashear |
| OF |
Sarah Johnson |
Fr. |
Geneva |
Highlands Ranch, Colo. | Mountain Vista |
| OF |
Leah Woytek |
Jr. |
Thiel |
Hillsville, Pa. | Mohawk |
| DP |
Madison Howell |
Jr. |
Chatham |
Huntington, W.Va. | Huntington |
| UTIL |
Jessica Kelley |
Sr. |
Thiel |
Freeport, Pa. | Freeport |
| UTIL |
Nicole West |
Fr. |
Geneva |
Glenwood, Md. | McDonough |
| P |
Celia Knappenberger |
Fr. |
Saint Vincent |
Sarver, Pa. | Knoch |
| P |
Madison Brown |
Fr. |
Westminster |
Lisbon, Ohio | East Liverpool |