| Honorable Mention |
| Position |
Name |
Class |
School |
Hometown | High School |
| 1B |
Justin Buberl |
So. |
Waynesburg University |
Westminster, Md. | Westminster |
| 1B |
Carmen Jansante |
Sr. |
Chatham University |
Bethel Park, Pa. | Bethel Park |
| 1B |
Daniel Patrice |
Jr. |
Thiel College |
Munich, Germany | EST |
| 2B |
Ryan Nickerson |
Sr. |
Bethany College |
Huntington Beach, Calif. | Huntington Beach |
| 2B |
Luke Zahren |
Sr. |
Washington & Jefferson College |
Ingomar, Pa. | North Allegheny |
| SS |
Forrest Beighley |
Sr. |
Geneva College |
Beaver Falls, Pa. | Blackhawk |
| 3B |
Micah Burke |
Jr. |
Grove City College |
Gilbert, Ariz. | EVAC |
| 3B |
Dante Parente |
Jr. |
Westminster College |
Beaver Falls, Pa. | Blackhawk |
| OF |
Josh Boeckmann |
Jr. |
Thomas More College |
Cincinnati, Ohio | Elder |
| OF |
Dante Dalesandro |
Jr. |
Washington & Jefferson College |
Pittsburgh, Pa. | Mount Lebanon |
| OF |
Jake Marino |
Sr. |
Thiel College |
Pittsfield, Pa. | Youngsville |
| OF |
Mitch Nordstrom |
Jr. |
Waynesburg University |
Bethel Park, Pa. | Bethel Park |
| OF |
Blaise Ostertag |
Jr. |
Thomas More College |
Burlington, Ky. | Conner |
| DH |
Mike Douds |
Jr. |
Westminster College |
Erie, Pa. | Cathedral Prep. |
| DH |
Matt Wellbrock |
So. |
Thomas More College |
Cincinnati, Ohio | Elder |
| P |
Will Bowser |
Sr. |
Washington & Jefferson College |
Burgettstown, Pa. | Weirton Madonna (W.Va.) |
| P |
Matt Heslin |
Sr. |
Washington & Jefferson College |
McDonald, Pa. | Fort Cherry |
| P |
Clay Martin |
Jr. |
Washington & Jefferson College |
Canonsburg, Pa. | Canon-McMillan |
| P |
Santino Platt |
Jr. |
Washington & Jefferson College |
Pittsburgh, Pa. | Our Lady of the Sacred Heart |
| P |
Cory Pullen |
Jr. |
Westminster College |
Wexford, Pa. | North Allegheny |